By Betsy and Chuck Vail 04/20/2025
When smoking a turkey, it’s important to note that big isn’t better. It’s best to use a bird that is about 12-15 lbs. If the bird is larger than that, then it may not reach temperature and cook completely inside. If you’re planning a party, it’s better to use multiple 12-15 lb. birds rather than larger birds.
Ingredients:
Butter boobs:
- 2 sticks of butter, softened (1 c total)
- 1 tsp salt
- 2 Tbs onion powder
- 2 Tbs smoked paprika
- a dash of liquid smoke
Rub:
- ½ c brown sugar
- 1 tsp salt
- 3 Tbs onion powder
- 3 Tbs smoked paprika
- ¼ tsp pepper
Turkey:
Directions:
Butter Boobs:
- To make the butter boobs, combine the softened butter with all the spices until thoroughly mixed.
- Line 2 matching small bowls with wax paper. Divide the seasoned butter evenly and place the mixture into the 2 bowls. Be sure to smooth the surface of the butter, then place them into the freezer to harden.
Rub:
Combine and mix all ingredients in a bowl and set aside.
Turkey:
- Place the thawed turkey on a cookie sheet over the kitchen sink because the process may be a bit messy.
- Remove the neck, bag of anatomical parts, and any pin feathers. Pat the bird dry with paper towels.
- Drizzle a small amount of olive oil over the bird and rub the skin until all sides of the outside surface are lightly covered.
- Using your fingertips, slowly move your hand up to separate the skin from both sides of the breast meat. Do your best not to tear the skin.
- Remove the wax paper, then add 1 butter boob to each breast (between the skin and the meat) so that the turkey looks like it has breast implants. When cooking, the butter will slowly melt over the turkey meat to baste and season it making it absolutely delicious!
- Using the rub, PAT the seasoning on all sides of the exterior of the turkey.
- Set your smoker to 225-250 F.
- Smoke about 30 minutes per pound, so for example, a 12-lb turkey will take about 6 hours to cook completely.
- Add a meat thermometer(s) to the thickest part of the breast meat, but be sure not to imbed it so far that it touches the bone or the empty cavity.
- Fire Note: Be sure to watch the smoker. As the butter melts and drips, the oils and juices may catch fire. If this happens, have a spray bottle with water handy so the flames can be extinguished quickly. The fire will char your bird, and it tastes better with smoke instead of char.
- Smoke the turkey until the internal temperature is 160 F, or 170 F in the thigh.
- Allow the turkey to rest for about 15 minutes. The turkey will continue to cook and will reach the desired temperatures of 165 F, or 175 F in the thigh.
I have it on excellent foodie authority that this smoked turkey is the most moist, delicious turkey that one could ever have and will be the standard that all other turkeys will try to live up to! It’s the food of amazing turkey dreams! It’s more time and effort than roasting in an oven bag, but it’s really worth it! Enjoy!